The List of Prompts Has Been Reduced and Now Has Arrows Above and Below It

I believe this is how I may have cause this problem.

I was doing Migration(MIG) testing the “Prompts” section of “Preferences”. I selected “All on one page" in both PROD and MIG, and then selected the default values.

I reset back to my original setting of “Each on a separate page.”
The report that I was testing originally showed a list of eleven prompts. Any one of them could be selected by clicking upon it.
Now, the prompt selections are limited to just a list of five, with arrows above and below the list. Also, I cannot select any prompt that I want; I must click the "Next" box and do them in the order listed. Additionally, the display format has completely changed.
I have no clue how to get back to seeing normal list of eleven prompts on one page.
 
Thanks